This week's company
One fictional company and three of its prospective customers. The company is invented; the physics and the real missions it's modeled on are not.
Engage ComputeData center modules for space
What space weather does to a data center
Storms add drag
A geomagnetic storm heats the upper atmosphere and makes it swell. Satellites in low orbit slow down and sink faster. In February 2022, a minor storm brought down 38 new Starlink satellites.
Single particles cause errors
One cosmic ray or solar proton crossing a chip can flip a bit (a wrong 1 or 0) or trigger a latchup (a short that stays on until the power is cut). Shielding doesn't stop the most energetic particles.
Dose builds up
Years of radiation slowly damage a chip's insulating layers until its transistors stop switching cleanly. Shielding helps here. How fast the dose builds depends on the site.
The Van Allen radiation belts
Earth's magnetic field traps charged particles in two doughnut-shaped belts. A trapped particle spirals around a magnetic field line, bounces between the north and south "mirror points" where the field gets stronger (about once a second), and slowly drifts around the planet. Together these motions fill out the belts.
- Inner belt: energetic protons, tens to hundreds of MeV, from roughly 1,000 km out to about 6,000 km or a little beyond, above the equator. They are most intense around 3,000 km. They pass through shielding and cause both dose damage and bit flips.
- Outer belt: mostly energetic electrons, from roughly 13,000 km outward, swelling and shrinking with solar storms. They build up electric charge on and inside spacecraft.
- Latitude matters. The belts follow the field lines, so they sit highest over the equator and dip lower toward the poles (the "horns"). Over the polar caps the field lines open into space, so nothing is trapped there, but particles from solar storms can stream straight down.
- The South Atlantic Anomaly. Earth's magnetic field is tilted and off-center. Over South America and the South Atlantic it is weaker, and the inner belt dips to about 200 km. Satellites in low orbit cross it several times a day.
Sources differ on exactly where each belt begins and ends; the figures here are approximate.
How data moves through a space data center
1. Up
From the customer's ground station by radio or laser, or through a relay satellite. Data from other satellites can arrive by laser links between satellites, without touching the ground. Uplinks are usually slower than downlinks.
2. In space
Data is written to solid-state drives, processed by GPUs or TPUs, and the results are stored until the next downlink. Everything runs on solar power and sheds heat through radiators. Error-correcting memory and regular saves of progress handle bit flips.
3. Down
By laser or radio during passes over ground stations, continuously from GEO, or through a relay from the Moon. Clouds block laser links, so operators need several ground stations in different weather zones.
Rule of thumb: the link to the ground is the narrowest part of the pipe. Computing in space makes the most sense when the data starts in space, or when the results are much smaller than the input.
Engage Compute's four sites
Light delay is set by physics: radio and laser signals travel at the speed of light. Link speeds, sunlight and radiation are simplified for teaching.
| LEO 550 km | MEO 6,000 km | GEO 35,786 km | Moon south pole | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Orbit | Low Earth orbit, dawn-dusk sun-synchronous: it rides the line between day and night | Medium Earth orbit | Geostationary: stays over one spot on the equator | On the surface, on a ridge near the south pole, buried under regolith |
| Round-trip light delay to Earth | about 4 ms | about 40 ms | about 240 ms | about 2.6 s |
| Downlink to Earth* (average) | 20 Gbps (up to 100 Gbps during passes over a laser ground station) | 10 Gbps, with an hour or more of contact per pass | 5 Gbps, always in view of one ground station | 1 Gbps through a relay satellite (NASA's 2013 Moon laser link reached 0.622 Gbps) |
| Uplink from Earth* (average) | 10 Gbps | 5 Gbps | 2 Gbps | 1 Gbps (a relay built for two-way traffic) |
| Sunlight | Almost constant | Mostly sunlit, short eclipses | Sunlit except up to 72 min a day in eclipse seasons | Sunlit most of the year, but dark spells of several days need large batteries |
| Radiation | Low to moderate. Below the belts, but its near-polar path crosses the South Atlantic Anomaly, the belts' high-latitude horns and the poles, where solar storm particles get in | Very high. Inside the inner proton belt; needs radiation-hardened parts and heavy shielding, which cancels out the cost advantage of commercial GPUs | Moderate. Outer-belt electrons, and charging of surfaces during storms | High at the surface, with no magnetic field or air. A couple of metres of regolith blocks most of it |
| Other hazards | Storm drag; crowded with debris (see Crystals and Collisions) | Few | Crowded, regulated orbital slots | Constant micrometeoroid hits on anything exposed; the module must be buried by robots, as in Who Builds the Moon? |
| Life and cost* | About 5 years, then replaced. Cheapest to reach | About 5 to 10 years, and only with costly hardened parts and shielding. More costly to reach | About 15 years. More costly to reach; can't be serviced | Longer lifetime if buried. By far the most expensive: launch plus landing |
* Link speeds, sunlight, radiation, life and cost are illustrative examples, not current data. Light delay is set by physics and is the minimum: real networks add routing and processing time on top.
Delay and transfer calculator
Pick a site, a direction and a data size to see the light delay and how long the data takes to move at that site's link speed.
Transfer time = data × 8 ÷ link speed. 1 TB = 8,000 gigabits.
What Earth charges: the price to beat
Engage Compute's customers can always rent a data center on Earth instead. List prices from the three biggest cloud companies in U.S. regions, November 2026 (long-term contracts cost less):
| Item | Amazon Web Services | Microsoft Azure | Google Cloud |
|---|---|---|---|
| One AI chip for an hour | $6.88 (NVIDIA H100) | about $12.29 (NVIDIA H100) | $2.70 (Google TPU) |
| Storing 1 TB for a month (read often) | about $23 | about $18 | about $20 |
| Storing 1 TB for a month (archive, rarely read) | about $1 | about $1 to $4 | about $1.20 |
| Uploading data | Free | Free | Free |
| Downloading 1 TB to the internet | about $90 | about $87 | about $120 |
Sources: AI chips: AWS (OpsLyft), Azure (Spheron), Google Cloud TPU pricing. Storage: AWS S3 (CloudForecast), all three clouds (Finout). Downloads: AWS (EgressCost), Google Cloud (EgressCost), Azure (OpsLyft).
Round-trip delay on Earth
| Between data centers in one cloud region | about 1 ms |
| Home broadband to a nearby data center | about 10–20 ms |
| U.S. coast to coast by fiber | about 60–80 ms* |
| Starlink user to the internet | about 25–40 ms |
| Internet through a GEO satellite | about 600–750 ms |
Sources: AWS Architecture Blog (within a region); Ookla via RCR Wireless (home broadband); Ookla via Tesla North (Starlink and GEO); CommScope (speed of light in fiber, for the coast-to-coast estimate).
A TPU and a GPU do different amounts of work per hour, so prices per chip aren't a straight comparison. * Estimate: light in fiber travels at about two-thirds of its speed in vacuum.
Where should the work go?
You are Engage Compute's site engineers. Three customers want to sign up. For each one, pick the best site and a second choice, and name the one factor that decided it. Then pick the site Engage Compute should build first.
Training an AI model
A lunar base
A bank's nightly backup
The three customers at a glance
| Card | Data in, and where it starts | Computing in space | Data out | Delay need | How often |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1. AI training | 500 TB from Earth | Heavy: about 1,000 GPUs, about 1 MW, nonstop for 3 months | The finished model: 2 TB | Doesn't matter | Once each way |
| 2. Lunar base | About 200 GB a day, starting on the Moon | Light but urgent: rover hazard checks, base operations | About 10–20 GB a day to Earth | Under 0.5 s for rovers | Daily |
| 3. Bank backup | 2 TB from Earth | Almost none: checking the copy is intact | Almost nothing; after a disaster, everything (60 TB or more) | Doesn't matter, but must finish in 8 hours | Nightly |
Data volumes are illustrative examples, not current data.
Your log
Fill in the log in the student deck, one row per card. Use the site table, the calculator and the Earth prices above. If none of Engage Compute's sites can serve a customer, say so.
| Card | Best site | Second choice | Deciding factor |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | |||
| 2 | |||
| 3 |
Use the calculator to find how long it takes to upload card 1's 500 TB of training data to each of the four sites. Which sites are practical for a 3-month job?
The bank in card 3 keeps its last 30 nightly backups, 2 TB each. Using the AWS prices in "What Earth charges," what does storing them cost per month if they're read often, and in archive? What would Engage Compute have to offer to win this customer?
Engage Compute can build at only one site first. Which one, and which customers does that choice give up?
Due before November 11, 3 pm
Answer in this week's student deck and upload it to Canvas.
Storm warning
This builds on the work you did in class. For each card, use the best site you chose in your log.
NOAA's Space Weather Prediction Center issues a watch: a fast coronal mass ejection is expected to arrive in about 36 hours, with a G4 (severe) geomagnetic storm and an S3 (strong) solar radiation storm.
For each card, what is at risk at the site you chose, and what should Engage Compute's operators do before the storm arrives?
Check the pitch: power and heat
Engage Compute is raising money for a 1 MW module in LEO. Its pitch deck says, "Power is free and cooling in space is free." Check both claims with two rules of thumb.
Two rules of thumb
Solar power. Sunlight in Earth orbit delivers 1,361 W per square metre. Good space solar cells turn about 30% of that into electricity, so each m² of array gives about 400 W.
Getting rid of heat. Nearly all the electricity a computer uses ends up as heat. In a vacuum there is no air or water to carry it away, so heat can only leave as infrared radiation from a radiator panel. A two-sided panel at about room temperature (27 °C) radiates about 800 W per m².
Area needed = power ÷ watts per m²
These ignore sunlight and Earth's heat landing on the radiator, which make the real radiator larger.
About how many m² of solar array does a 1 MW module need? How many m² of radiator?
Every square metre has to be launched. Is power "free" in space? Is cooling? What do you tell the investment committee?
A real startup, Starcloud, has pitched a 5 GW data center powered by a solar array of about 4 km². How much sunlight falls on 4 km² in orbit? What does that tell you about the pitch, and what question would you ask the founders?
A satellite broadband company runs a constellation of about a dozen satellites in an equatorial orbit at about 8,000 km. It sells internet links to cruise ships, airlines, governments and mobile phone networks in remote areas, with round-trip times under 150 ms, and has operated there for more than ten years. Engage Compute's MEO site is at 6,000 km. Why would a company choose 8,000 km over 6,000 km? And why that altitude rather than low Earth orbit or GEO?
TRL
For worked examples, see Ready for the Moon? Use it and the definitions below for Homework 3.
TRL definitions (1–9)
| TRL | Technology Readiness (NASA) |
|---|
Rate what has flown
These are real. For each item, read the evidence, pick a TRL and defend it in the box. There is no single right answer: the grade is for the reasons you give, not the number.
Which of these ratings matters most for the site you chose for Engage Compute in class, and why?
Acronyms and units
| Acronym | Meaning |
|---|---|
| AI | Artificial intelligence |
| DNA | Deoxyribonucleic acid, the molecule that carries genetic information |
| FCC | Federal Communications Commission, the U.S. agency that licenses satellites’ radio use |
| G4, S3 | Levels on NOAA’s space weather scales: G4 is a severe geomagnetic storm, S3 a strong solar radiation storm (each scale runs 1 to 5) |
| GEO | Geostationary orbit, 35,786 km above the equator, where a satellite stays over one spot |
| GPU | Graphics processing unit, the chip most AI computing runs on |
| HPE | Hewlett Packard Enterprise |
| IM-2 | Intuitive Machines’ second Moon landing mission (2025) |
| ISS | International Space Station |
| LEO | Low Earth orbit, up to about 2,000 km |
| MEO | Medium Earth orbit, between low Earth orbit and GEO |
| NASA | National Aeronautics and Space Administration |
| NOAA | National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration, whose Space Weather Prediction Center issues space weather forecasts |
| TPU | Tensor processing unit, Google’s chip designed for AI |
| TRL | Technology Readiness Level, NASA’s 1-to-9 scale of how proven a technology is |
| Unit | Meaning |
|---|---|
| ms | Millisecond, one thousandth of a second |
| km | Kilometer |
| W, MW, GW | Watt, megawatt (a million watts), gigawatt (a billion watts) |
| m², km² | Square meter, square kilometer |
| MeV | Million electron volts, a measure of a particle’s energy |
| GB, TB | Gigabyte, terabyte (1 TB = 1,000 GB = 8,000 gigabits) |
| Mbps, Gbps | Megabits per second, gigabits per second: link speed |