EMGT 5061 · Current policy challenges

Orbit Commons

Every satellite launched, abandoned, or hit adds to a commons that all operators share. The IN CLASS section is for class. The full simulator for your homework is in the HOMEWORK section below it.

The disposal decision

The decision

Your company, Sky Island Wildfire Watch, will fly a satellite fleet that images wildfires across the Southwest. Engineering has narrowed it to three options. The customer requires images at 5 m resolution or better, and all three options meet that.

OptionThe fleetImage sharpnessFleet costWhat happens to satellites that die
A. Lower orbit (about 400–700 km)18 satellites3 m$90MThey fall back to Earth on their own within about 5 years.
B. Higher orbit, full disposal (about 700–1,000 km)10 satellites, each with a deorbit thruster plus backup power and radioAbout 5 m$65MNearly all are deorbited on time.
C. Higher orbit, thruster only (about 700–1,000 km)10 satellites with a deorbit thruster but no backup systemsAbout 5 m$59MAbout 1 in 10 dies before it can deorbit, and stays in orbit for centuries.

Questions

  1. Which option would your CFO pick? Which would you pick as the engineering manager responsible for this mission? If your answers differ, explain why.
  2. What would make sustainability the business choice for other reasons? Choose two of these stakeholders and give a reason for each that could change the CFO's mind: insurers, customers, investors and lenders, regulators, the public, or the orbit itself.

What if 100 companies chose the same way?

Your company will launch either 18 or 10 satellites. On its own, that won't make a noticeable difference: about 17,000 satellites are already operating in orbit. But hundreds of companies are making choices like yours.

Suppose 100 companies each launch a fleet like yours, and keep it flying by replacing satellites as they wear out. Click Baseline: Unchanged number of active satellites and pin it. The dashed line is the debris already in orbit, if no one, including your company, adds anything new. Then click each option. The gap between the solid line and the dashed line is what that choice adds.

Note: In every run, including the baseline, today's operators keep their 17,000 satellites flying by replacing them as they wear out. Only the 100 new fleets change from run to run.

  1. What does the gap between the lines tell you about one company's responsibility when it shares orbit with many others?

Objects in orbit

Tracked objects larger than about 10 cm, 2026–2126. Hover or use the arrow keys to read a year.

Due before October 14, 3 pm

An individual assignment, about 45 minutes.

In class, you and your partner chose how Sky Island Wildfire Watch should fly its fleet. This homework has three parts:

  1. Test what happens if the whole industry (100 companies) makes the same choice that your company has made.
  2. See what an orbital-use fee would do.
  3. Now that you have a better understanding of the different scenarios, make the case to your CEO.

The three options

The customer requires images at 5 m resolution or better. All three options meet that.

OptionThe fleetImage sharpnessFleet costWhat happens to satellites that die
A. Lower orbit (about 400–700 km)18 satellites3 m$90MThey fall back to Earth on their own within about 5 years.
B. Higher orbit, full disposal (about 700–1,000 km)10 satellites, each with a deorbit thruster plus backup power and radioAbout 5 m$65MNearly all are deorbited on time.
C. Higher orbit, thruster only (about 700–1,000 km)10 satellites with a deorbit thruster but no backup systemsAbout 5 m$59MAbout 1 in 10 dies before it can deorbit, and stays in orbit for centuries.

Part 1: What if 100 companies chose the same way?

Use the simulator below. The buttons under Your in-class decision set everything up for you.

  1. Click Baseline: Unchanged number of active satellites, then click Pin this run for comparison. This is the debris already in orbit, with today's 17,000 satellites replaced as they wear out but nothing new added.
  2. Click Option A, Option B, and Option C in turn. For each, record the tracked debris in 2126, the verdict, and how it compares with the pinned baseline (the last sentence in the verdict box).
RunTracked debris in 2126VerdictCompared with the baseline
Baseline—
Option A
Option B
Option C
  1. Which option adds the least debris compared with the baseline, and which adds the most?
  2. Option B costs $6M more than option C. What does that $6M buy for the orbital environment?
  3. Who pays for the extra debris from option C: your company, other operators, or someone else?

Part 2: An orbital-use fee

Some economists propose charging operators a fee for every satellite they keep in orbit. One study (Rao, Burgess & Kaffine, PNAS, 2020) proposed a fee that rises annually to about $235,000 per satellite per year by 2040. On that path, the fee in 2026 works out to about $37,500 per satellite. Suppose that fee applies to your company's fleet starting in 2026.

  1. What would the fee cost each option per year in 2026? Keep in mind that it rises to $235,000 per satellite per year by 2040.
  2. Which option does the fee favor, and why?
  3. Is that the outcome a regulator worried about debris would want? Suggest one way to design the fee so it rewards responsible disposal.

Part 3: Your recommendation to the CEO

Choose one format: a one-page memo, or a short slide deck of 3–5 slides. Either way, cover:

  1. The option you recommend, and whether Parts 1 and 2 changed your in-class choice.
  2. The business case for sustainability: how responsible disposal pays off for the company, through customers, investors, insurers, regulators, reputation, or the long-term value of the orbit you depend on.
  3. The evidence: the costs above and your simulator results.
  4. The one assumption you would most want an expert to check before the company commits.

What to submit

Answer on the student slide deck, then submit the whole deck before October 14, 3 pm. It holds your in-class answers and all three homework parts:

  • Your answers to in-class questions 1–3.
  • Your Part 1 results table and answers.
  • Your Part 2 fee table and answers.
  • Your Part 3 recommendation: 3–5 slides added to the deck, or a one-page memo attached instead.

Want to go further? The More scenarios buttons and every setting below are yours to explore.

The simulator

This runs the same model as the in-class chart, so the same option draws the same lines. It adds more ways to look at each run:

  • More scenarios buttons, beyond the in-class decision.
  • Sliders and settings for every input. They rerun the model as soon as you change them. Moving one turns off the highlighted scenario button. Pin a run first if you want to compare.
  • All LEO, Lower orbit (about 400–700 km), and Higher orbit (about 700–1,000 km) buttons on the first chart. The in-class chart always shows all of LEO combined. Splitting it shows which altitude range the orbital debris grows in.
  • Log scale, which keeps very large runs readable.
  • The Kessler test chart, which compares the fragments collisions create each year in higher orbit with the fragments the atmosphere removes. When the pink line stays above the green one, debris grows on its own.
  • Summary numbers above the charts, and a year-by-year table at the bottom.

In short, the in-class chart shows what happens. These charts show why.

Your in-class decision: 100 companies like yours
More scenarios

Added on top of the 17,000 satellites already flying, which are always replaced as they wear out. The active count has grown by about 3,000 a year recently (McDowell).

Where new satellites fly

Dead objects fall back within years from lower orbit, but stay for centuries in higher orbit.

The rest die in orbit and drift as derelicts.

Deorbit deadline after end of mission

Active debris removal, largest dead objects first.

Charged per satellite per year. Satellites worth less than the fee don't get launched.

Objects in orbit

Tracked objects larger than about 10 cm, 2026–2126. Hover or use the arrow keys to read a year.

The Kessler test: higher orbit

New fragments from collisions each year, against fragments the atmosphere removes. When the pink line stays above the green one, debris grows on its own.

Show the numbers for this run

About the model

This is a teaching model, not a forecast. It follows the structure of published source-sink debris models such as MIT's MOCAT: launches add satellites, drag and disposal remove objects, and collisions turn intact objects into fragments. It collapses low Earth orbit into two orbits, lower (about 400–700 km, modeled at 550 km) and higher (about 700–1,000 km, modeled at 900 km), and steps forward in fractions of a year. Starting counts come from ESA. The rates inside the model are tuned so it behaves the way published studies describe, and the table marks which values are which.

In every run, today's 17,000 satellites stay in orbit: operators replace them as they wear out, so the number of active satellites never drops below today's level. The launch setting and the scenarios only add new satellites on top of that fleet. Two other simplifications matter most. Each orbit is treated as evenly mixed, so any two objects in the same orbit can collide. And fragments in lower orbit fall back within a couple of years, so a runaway cascade can only develop in higher orbit. Real studies find the same pattern: altitudes near 900–1,000 km are where debris can feed on itself.

ParameterValueBasis
Active satellites today17,000Sourced: Jonathan McDowell counts 16,913 active satellites (30 Sep 2026), nearly all in LEO.
Today's fleet in every run17,000 in lower orbit, replaced as they wear out: 5-year life, 90% deorbited within about 6 monthsAssumption: today's operators keep their fleets flying. The launch setting adds satellites on top of this.
Derelicts in LEO today6,800Approximate: inactive payloads plus rocket bodies (971) in LEO, from ESA DISCOS.
Tracked fragments in LEO today5,500Sourced: fragmentation debris (4,750) plus mission-related objects (726), ESA DISCOS.
Split between orbitsLower: 1,500 derelicts, 1,500 fragments. Higher: 5,300, 4,000Assumption: older derelicts and fragments sit mostly at 700–1,000 km; today's constellations fly low.
Natural decay, lower orbitIntact 5 yr, fragments 2 yrApproximate: dead satellites near 550 km reenter within about five years.
Natural decay, higher orbitIntact 200 yr, fragments 100 yrApproximate: objects near 900 km stay up for a century or more.
Collision rate in higher orbit today0.2 per yearTuned: with no launches, higher-orbit debris keeps growing, as ESA (2025) and Liou & Johnson (2006) report.
Fragments per collision1,000 intact–intact, 200 intact–fragment, 20 fragment–fragmentTuned: Iridium–Cosmos (2009) still had about 1,500 tracked pieces in orbit seven years later.
Exposure of active satellites5%Assumption: they dodge tracked objects but can't dodge untracked ones.
Time to deorbit when compliantHalf the deadline, or half the natural decay time if shorterAssumption: disposals spread evenly across the allowed window.
Fee responseValue per satellite spread evenly from $0 to $1M a yearAssumption: satellites worth less than the fee are not launched.
Orbital-use fee path$37,500 in 2026, +14%/yr, $235,000 by 2040, then flatSourced: Rao, Burgess & Kaffine (2020) compute $235,000 per satellite-year in 2040, rising 14% a year.

Sources

Every source used to build this page, and what each one supplied.