How we compare the powers
Today's lecture looks at every country through the same seven questions. Use them in both exercises.
1. Governance
Who runs the space program, and where does it sit in government?
2. Money
How big is the budget, and who pays: civil, military or commercial?
3. Access to space
Can it launch its own satellites and people? On how many rockets, from how many pads?
4. Flagship programs
What does it fly that others notice: stations, Moon missions, navigation?
5. Commercial policy tools
How does it grow companies: contracts, licensing, funds, technology transfer?
6. International alignment
Who are its partners? Artemis Accords, ILRS, both or neither?
7. Workforce
Where do its engineers come from, and can it keep them?
Stress test: how full is full stack?
Each shock card below puts one of the six full-stack powers in a real crisis: its main way to reach orbit is suddenly gone. What happens next? All six events really happened.
How this works
You're running a country's space program when disaster strikes. Your group is assigned two cards.
Dependence costs more than money. When a country relies on someone else to reach orbit, it can also pay in:
- Leverage: the provider can use your need as a bargaining chip.
- Schedule: you fly when they can fit you in, not when you want to.
- Skills: your own workforce and industry shrink while you wait.
- Prestige and autonomy: you can't claim independence in space.
- Security: your satellites or astronauts sit inside someone else's system.
We put it all together at the end. Each group reports back on its two cards, and then the whole class ranks all six powers from most to least resilient.
Group A
China
July 2, 2017The second Long March 5, China's most powerful rocket, fails minutes after liftoff because of a fault in a first-stage engine. China's lunar sample return mission, its space station modules and its first Mars mission all need this rocket.
Source, to open after you answer in your student deck: AP via Phys.org: China rocket failure likely to set back next space missions
Europe
July 2023The last Ariane 5 flies. Its replacement, Ariane 6, is years late. The smaller Vega-C has been grounded since a failure in December 2022. Russia pulled its Soyuz rockets out of Europe's spaceport in 2022. ESA has satellites ready to go.
Source, to open after you answer in your student deck: ESA: Ariane 5 bows out in style
Group B
India
May 2025 and January 2026PSLV, India's workhorse rocket with a long record of successes, fails twice in eight months, both times in its third stage. The second flight was a commercial mission carrying an Earth observation satellite and 15 smaller satellites, some for foreign customers.
Source, to open after you answer in your student deck: NASASpaceflight: India's PSLV and its second third-stage failure
Japan
December 22, 2025Japan's flagship H3 rocket fails: separating the nose cone damages the satellite's mount, and the Michibiki 5 navigation satellite is lost. Japan retired its older H-IIA rocket in June 2025.
Source, to open after you answer in your student deck: JAXA: Launch failure of the 8th H3 launch vehicle
Group C
Russia
November 27, 2025The Soyuz MS-28 crew reaches orbit safely, but the launch collapses the mobile service platform at Baikonur's Site 31 into the flame trench below the pad. Site 31 is Russia's only pad for sending crews and cargo to the ISS.
Source, to open after you answer in your student deck: RussianSpaceWeb: Baikonur Site 31 accident
United States
July 2011The Space Shuttle flies its last mission. NASA has no other vehicle that can launch its astronauts, and the International Space Station still needs crews. The replacement spacecraft are years away.
Source, to open after you answer in your student deck: NASA: STS-135, the space shuttle's grand finale
For each of your cards
Record your answers in this week's student deck. Once you have finished your homework, upload the whole student deck to Canvas.
Answer first, then check. Decide from what you know about that country's space system before you look up what really happened.
Capacity lost: can the country no longer launch its crews, its payloads (satellites and cargo), or both?
For Q2 to Q6, imagine the shock happens today. Some of these events are years old, and the options for a backup have changed since then. In 2011, for example, no American company could fly NASA astronauts; SpaceX's Crew Dragon didn't carry a crew until 2020. Answer with today's rockets, companies and partners.
What's the backup for each capacity lost: another domestic rocket or pad, another country's rocket, or nothing? Answer separately for crews and payloads.
Who pays to recover?
Who does the country now depend on, and what does that dependence cost besides money?
Rate its resilience from 1 (no backup at all) to 5 (barely slowed down).
Justify your rating: which facts about the country's space ecosystem increased or lowered your resilience score?
Now look up what actually happened at the time. How does what really happened compare with your answers for today, and what explains the difference?
Whole class
Rank all six powers from most to least resilient. Is the biggest space program also the most resilient?
Is "full stack" the same as resilient? What would you add to the seven framework questions to capture the difference?
New Mexico, part 1: launch and test sites
New Mexico isn't a country, but it hosts a remarkable share of America's space activity. Over the next two weeks you'll map it. Today you start with the places where things are launched and tested.
Your task
Each group researches one New Mexico launch or test site, assigned below, and records it in the student deck. Group A: Spaceport America. Group B: White Sands Missile Range. Group C: NASA White Sands Test Facility.
Record:
| Name | The site, and who runs it |
| Location | Nearest town and county |
| Product or capability | What it launches or tests, or the main service it sells |
| TRL | The TRL (1–9) of that main product or capability. See the TRL definitions. |
| Why New Mexico? | What about this location makes it work here: airspace, altitude, open land, weather, a lab nearby? |
| Value-chain position | Upstream, midstream or downstream. See the value chain. |
MRL isn't needed for a site. You'll rate MRL for a company in the homework.
Due before November 18, 3 pm
Answer in this week's student deck and upload it to Canvas.
New Mexico, part 2: labs, universities and companies
On your own, find one entity in New Mexico in each of the three categories below, and record the same fields you used in class. For the company, also rate its MRL.
Labs and military research
National laboratories and military research or test organizations working on space.
Universities and observatories
Universities, research centers and observatories with space work.
Companies
Private companies with a space product or service, based or operating in New Mexico.
| Field | What to record |
|---|---|
| Name | The entity |
| Location | Nearest town and county |
| Product | Its main space product, technology or capability |
| TRL | TRL (1–9) of that product |
| MRL (company only) | MRL (0–9) of the company's product. |
| Why New Mexico? | What about the location makes it work here |
| Value-chain position | Upstream, midstream or downstream |
| Source | A link to the page where you found your information. If there's no link, explain where it came from, such as a conversation, an event or a printed source. |
Of the four entities you've worked on (your group's site from class plus your three), which matters most if New Mexico wanted its own space strategy? Why? Answer in three to five sentences. We'll use your answers next week.
TRL, MRL and the value chain
For worked TRL and MRL examples, see Ready for the Moon?
TRL definitions (1–9)
| TRL | Technology Readiness (NASA) |
|---|
MRL definitions (0–9)
| MRL | Market Readiness (Mealing, Starbridge Venture Capital) |
|---|
TRL asks "does it work?" MRL asks "has the market been tested: who are the customers, do they want it, and will they pay?" A product can be TRL 9 and still be MRL 3 if no one has tested who will buy it.
The space value chain
| Position | What belongs there |
|---|---|
| Upstream | Research and development, manufacturing, testing and launch |
| Midstream | Satellite operations and ground infrastructure |
| Downstream | Data, analytics, applications and services for end users |
The same framework from Commercial Space Markets. Some entities sit in more than one position: name the main one and say why.
Sources: TRL: NASA, Technology Readiness Levels. MRL: Michael Mealing, “Market Readiness Levels: Product Development Metrics for Investment and Deployment Decision Making,” Starbridge Venture Capital. Value chain: New Space Economy, “What Is the Value Chain of the Space Economy?” and OECD, The Space Economy at a Glance 2026.
Acronyms
| Acronym | Meaning |
|---|---|
| ESA | European Space Agency |
| H-IIA, H3 | Japan's previous and current flagship rockets |
| ILRS | International Lunar Research Station, the China–Russia lunar base project |
| ISS | International Space Station |
| MRL | Market Readiness Level, a 0-to-9 scale (Mealing, Starbridge Venture Capital) of how well a product's customers, value proposition and business model have been tested, from a perceived need to a go-to-market decision |
| NASA | National Aeronautics and Space Administration |
| PSLV | Polar Satellite Launch Vehicle, India's workhorse rocket |
| TRL | Technology Readiness Level, NASA's 1-to-9 scale of how proven a technology is |