EMGT 5061 · Introduction to Space Industry · Fall 2026

Emerging Space Nations, Specialists and Climbers

Global Space Ecosystems II: Luxembourg, New Zealand, Singapore, the United Kingdom, the UAE, Australia, South Korea and Senegal. None of them can do everything in space, so each picks a playbook.

In class, you first discuss how countries handle belonging to both Moon clubs, the Artemis Accords and the International Lunar Research Station (ILRS). Then you spend a country's space budget and see the implications.

For homework, you pick a playbook for New Mexico and pitch it to the governor.

November 18, 2026Dr. Bidushi BhattacharyaRecord your answers in this week's student deck, and upload it to Canvas when you're finished with your homework

Two Moon clubs: the Artemis Accords and the ILRS

The Artemis Accords

The Artemis Accords are a set of principles, drafted by NASA and the US State Department, for peaceful and responsible exploration of the Moon, Mars, comets and asteroids. They aren't a treaty and cost nothing to sign. Signers commit to:

  • being open about what they do in space, and releasing their scientific data
  • building systems that can work with each other's, and helping astronauts in distress
  • protecting historic sites, planning for the safe disposal of debris, and setting up "safety zones" so missions don't interfere with one another
  • following shared rules for extracting and using resources found in space

What a country gets: a voice in writing the rules for the Moon, and a door into NASA's Artemis program. In March 2026 NASA announced a Moon Base at the lunar south pole, to be built with companies and partner countries. Signing opens that door; the actual role (contracts, instruments on missions, astronaut seats, hardware for the base) comes through a separate deal with NASA.

Australia

A founding signer, October 2020. Its agency is building a small rover, Roo-ver, to go to the Moon with NASA. Roo-ver will scoop up lunar soil so NASA can try to extract oxygen from it, and is set to fly on a US commercial lander by 2030.

UAE

A founding signer, October 2020. Its planned airlock for NASA's Gateway was cancelled in March 2026. NASA has replaced Gateway with a Moon Base.

Senegal

Signed in July 2025, the 56th country to join and the fourth in Africa. It had already joined the ILRS ten months earlier (see below).

The International Lunar Research Station (ILRS)

The ILRS is a plan led by China and Russia, which signed an agreement in March 2021, to build a permanent research base near the Moon's south pole. Construction is planned for 2026 to 2035, starting with China's Chang'e-7 and Chang'e-8 missions. Unlike the Artemis Accords, its rules for members haven't been made public.

Who has joined: 13 countries as of July 2026. They are China, Russia, Azerbaijan, Belarus, Egypt, Kazakhstan, Nicaragua, Pakistan, Senegal, Serbia, South Africa, Thailand and Venezuela. China's space agency gives a bigger number, "17 countries and international organizations," because it also counts groups such as the Asia-Pacific Space Cooperation Organization.

What members expect to get: a role in a Moon base they could never build alone, such as room for an instrument or a small rover on a Chinese lunar mission, or running a ground station (Venezuela's role), plus Chinese training and technology. China is aiming for 50 countries, 500 research institutions and 5,000 scientists.

Artemis AccordsILRS
Pros
  • Free to sign, with published principles
  • The bigger club: 78 countries as of October 2026
  • A door into NASA's Artemis program and its planned Moon Base: contracts, instruments on missions, even astronaut seats
  • Joining means joining the Moon base project itself, with room on Chinese lunar missions
  • Chinese training and technology, often for countries with little access to US programs
  • China has already landed three times on the Moon and brought back samples
Cons
  • Signing alone brings no money or seats: each benefit is a separate deal with NASA
  • Lines a country up with the United States
  • NASA can change course: when it cancelled Gateway in 2026, partners' hardware, like the UAE's airlock, lost its home
  • Critics say its rules on using Moon resources stretch the Outer Space Treaty's ban on claiming territory
  • Its rules for members aren't public
  • The smaller club: 13 countries
  • US export rules can block a country from putting US-linked parts on Chinese missions
  • Schedule risk: Chang'e-7 was postponed in August 2026 with no new date

You can join both. Thailand (2024), Senegal (2025) and Serbia (2026) belong to both clubs, and the US says ILRS members are welcome to sign the Accords.

Partner diversification. For developing space nations like these three, joining both clubs is a strategy, not an accident. Signing the Artemis Accords (78 signers) and joining the ILRS (13 member countries) lets an emerging program reach scientific data, payload opportunities and ground station networks in both of the major space coalitions, instead of depending on one.

This section is the background for the in-class discussion question just below it.

Where our three countries stand

Australia

Artemis Accords only.

UAE

Artemis Accords, with ties to the ILRS.

  • University of Sharjah: in November 2023 it signed an agreement with China's Deep Space Exploration Laboratory to cooperate on the ILRS. That's a university signing, not the government.
  • Rashid 2 rover: in 2022 the UAE agreed to fly it on China's Chang'e-7. US export rules stopped it.
  • Not officially committed: Chinese and Russian officials have called the UAE an ILRS partner, but the UAE government has never confirmed joining, and it isn't on the list of member countries.

Senegal

Both clubs.

  • ILRS: joined September 5, 2024, through an agreement between its space agency, ASES, and China's space agency. The deal includes training Senegalese scientists and engineers for lunar missions.
  • Artemis Accords: signed July 24, 2025, at NASA headquarters.

Surviving the lunar night: RHUs and RTGs

A night at the Moon's south pole lasts about two weeks and is bitterly cold. NASA's Moon Base plan, announced at its "Ignition" event in March 2026, tests nuclear heat sources in its first phase, alongside solar power and, later, a fission reactor. Two kinds of nuclear device are often confused:

Radioisotope heater unit (RHU)Radioisotope thermoelectric generator (RTG)
MakesHeat only, about 1 watt eachElectricity, tens to hundreds of watts
SizeAbout 40 grams, the size of a C-cell batteryAbout 45 kilograms for a Mars rover's RTG
JobKeeps instruments and batteries from freezingPowers a spacecraft or rover
ExamplesTwo 15-watt heaters warmed Apollo 11's seismometer in 1969; Cassini carried 82 RHUsCassini carried three; Curiosity and Perseverance on Mars run on one each

Both use the heat of decaying plutonium-238, and neither is new. What's new is the fuel: Zeno Power's 5-watt americium-241 RHU is set to fly on a Firefly lander no earlier than 2028. Americium is easier to get than scarce plutonium-238. Why it matters for emerging nations: these heat sources take nuclear fuel and government approvals, so a country can't simply buy one. A partner that can supply them is what lets a payload survive the lunar night.

Sources: NASA, Artemis Accords; Australian Space Agency, Moon to Mars; Australian Space Agency, meet Roo-ver; Information Age, Roo-ver by 2030; NASA, UAE Gateway airlock; NASA, Moon Base plan; Khaleej Times, UAE after Gateway; Space.com, South Korea signs; Azmth, ILRS members and status; SpacePolicyOnline, countries in both clubs; SpaceNews, University of Sharjah joins ILRS; South China Morning Post, Rashid 2 blocked; Diplo, Artemis Accords reach 78; Universe Magazine, Senegal signs the Accords; BRICS Africa Channel, Senegal joins the ILRS; NASA, RHU fact sheet; NASA, Cassini's RTGs and RHUs; ANS, Moon Base phase one; World Nuclear News, Zeno RHU on Blue Ghost.

In class · Discussion · nothing to type in the student deck

An engineering manager's question

How should a systems engineering manager at an aerospace contractor handle hardware export controls (such as ITAR and EAR) when delivering a payload for a nation like Senegal or Thailand that holds formal memberships in both Artemis and the ILRS?

Background: the Two Moon clubs section just above, including the paragraph on partner diversification. ITAR and EAR are defined in the acronyms.

Four playbooks

Last week's full-stack powers can build, launch and operate almost everything themselves. Today's countries can't, so each chooses where to compete. We look at all of them through the same seven framework questions, listed below the playbooks.

Regulators

Luxembourg, New Zealand

Small countries that win with laws. Clear rules and fast licensing bring companies to them from abroad.

Hubs

Singapore, United Kingdom

Places where space companies and money gather: finance, insurance, talent and partnerships with bigger programs.

Nation-builders

UAE, Australia

Countries using space to build a new industry, a workforce and national pride, often by buying help from abroad at first.

Climbers

South Korea, Senegal

Countries climbing step by step toward full stack. South Korea is far up the ladder: its own rockets, its own satellites, and now the Moon. Senegal is on the first rung: a first satellite built with a partner, the next one on its own.

Each country is listed under the playbook it leans on most today, but most do more than one thing:

  • Luxembourg (regulator) is also a hub: it's home to SES, one of the world's largest satellite operators, and the government is its biggest shareholder.Goal: make Luxembourg Europe's home for commercial space, especially companies working on space resources. Space is part of a long-running plan to diversify an economy once built on steel and now on finance.
  • New Zealand (regulator) also launches: Rocket Lab flies from its soil.Goal: grow a high-value space industry built on its launch licensing and its southern location. It wants that growth to be safe and responsible and to serve its national interests, which is why it reviews every payload.
  • Singapore (hub) also builds satellites: ST Engineering's TeLEOS-1 (2015) and its radar satellite TeLEOS-2 (2023), both launched on Indian rockets.Goal: make space a growth sector for the economy and for skilled jobs, and be the region's hub for space companies. It also wants satellite capabilities that serve its own needs, such as climate monitoring and maritime security.
  • United Kingdom (hub) also licenses launches and has a spaceport in Cornwall.Goal: be one of the world's most innovative and attractive space economies, drawing companies and investment to the UK. It also wants to launch satellites from British soil for the first time and protect its defense interests in space.
  • UAE (nation-builder) also explores deep space, and spreads the work across partners: after Hope at Mars, its MBR Explorer is set to launch to the asteroid belt in March 2028 on Japan's H3 rocket, with the University of Colorado's LASP as a technical partner, while the mission's asteroid lander and its Sirb radar satellites are built at home.Goal: use space to diversify the economy away from oil, building an Emirati workforce and a home-grown space industry. Missions like Hope also aim to inspire young people and earn the country prestige.
  • Australia (nation-builder) also regulates launches: it licensed its first orbital spaceport and rocket, Gilmour Space's Eris, whose first launch attempt failed in 2025.Goal: triple the size of its space industry to A$12 billion and add 20,000 jobs by 2030, a target set in 2019. Since the 2023 cuts, the government pursues it mainly through regulation and by investing in companies rather than through grants.
  • South Korea (climber) already flies its own rocket, Nuri, and also still uses foreign rockets.Goal: become one of the world's leading space powers, with its own rockets, a Moon landing by 2032 and a Mars landing by 2045. It also wants Korean companies to win a much larger share of the global space market.
  • Senegal (climber) also spreads its bets across partners: its first satellite, GaindéSat-1A, was built with a French university and launched on a SpaceX rocket in 2024, and Senegal belongs to both Moon clubs (see Two Moon clubs).Goal: use satellite data to manage water, farming, climate and security, and build what its president called technological sovereignty. It wants Senegalese engineers, not foreign contractors, to build its future satellites.

The seven framework questions

  • Governance: who runs the space program, and where does it sit in government?
  • Money: how big is the budget, and who pays: civil, military or commercial?
  • Access to space: can it launch its own satellites and people, or does it buy launches abroad?
  • Flagship programs: what does it fly that others notice?
  • Commercial policy tools: how does it grow companies: contracts, licensing, funds, grants?
  • International alignment: who are its partners? Artemis Accords, ILRS, both or neither?
  • Workforce: where do its engineers come from, and can it keep them?
Small Group Exercise

Spend $1 billion

You run your country's space agency. The government has just given you $1 billion to spend over the next five years. What do you buy, and what happens when something goes wrong?

Group A · Nation-builder

Australia

Australia's space agency opened in 2018 with A$41 million (about $28 million) over four years. Your $1 billion is more than 30 times that start.

Group B · Nation-builder

United Arab Emirates

In 2022 the UAE created a National Space Fund of AED 3 billion (about $817 million). Your $1 billion is a bit more than that whole fund.

Group C · Climber

Senegal

Senegal doesn't publish an annual space budget, but assume it's $50 million a year. Your $1 billion is about 20 times that.

The rules

1

Budget: $1 billion total over five years. You can't go over.

2

Prices: buy only from the menu. Each price is a rounded, real cost from a country's program, in US dollars.

3

International partners: none of these three countries has yet reached orbit on its own rocket, so at least half your purchases must involve an international partner: another country's space agency, a foreign company or a foreign university. A launch bought abroad, or a satellite built with a foreign university, counts.

4

Big items: you can start something that costs more than you have left, or takes longer than five years, but it won't be finished. Say what you'll have at year five.

5

Repeats: you can buy an item more than once, such as several launches abroad. If your country already has something on the menu, you can still buy more of it, but say why.

6

Reasons: tie every purchase to one of the seven framework questions.

✎ Type into the student deck

How it runs

Record your answers in this week's student deck. Once you have finished your homework, upload the whole student deck to Canvas.

Step 1

Spend. Fill in your shopping list in the student deck: each item, its cost, the framework question it answers, and why you bought it.

Step 2

Twist. Partway through, your instructor deals your group a twist card based on what you bought: something goes wrong, as it did for real countries. Money you've already spent is gone. Rebalance what's left on the twist slide.

Step 3

Report back. Fill in the report-back slide below and present it to the class.

✎ Type into the student deck

Your report-back slide

Each group presents one slide from the student deck, with these six parts:

Q1

First purchase: what you bought first, and why.

Q2

The bottom line: total spent, money left, and what you'll actually have at year five.

Q3

Balance: which framework question got the most money, and which got none.

Q4

Twist: the card you got, and what you cut or added.

Q5

Playbook: does your spending fit your country's playbook, or would it move your country into a different one?

Check

Reality: your instructor shows what your country really bought first with the money it actually had, which was far less or far more than $1 billion. Compare priorities, not totals: did you put the same things first?

Due before December 2, 3 pm

Do both parts in this week's student deck, including your memo, then upload the one deck to Canvas.

Homework 2

A space playbook for New Mexico: memo to the governor

The governor of New Mexico wants a state space strategy and has asked you which playbook to follow. Use what you've built over the last two weeks: your group's site from class, your three entities from Homework 1, and your H1.1 answer.

Your budget: the state can put $100 million over five years into your plan. Price your choices with the menu.

✎ Type into the student deck Part A · In the student deck

New Mexico's playbook

Part A records your choices; the memo in Part B makes the case for them. Don't repeat your reasons in both places.

Step 1: choose New Mexico's playbook. Pick one of the four, or mix two, such as a regulator that's also a hub, if New Mexico's strengths call for it.

PlaybookWhat it means for New Mexico
RegulatorWin with rules: make New Mexico the easiest, clearest place to license and run a space business.
HubDraw companies and money: be the place where space firms, investors, talent and partners gather.
Nation-builderUse space to build a new industry and workforce, buying help from outside at first.
ClimberBuild up your own capabilities step by step: your own launches, satellites and missions.
Mix of twoCombine two of the above; in the memo, say what each one contributes.

Step 2: answer each of the seven framework questions for New Mexico.

Framework questionWhat to record
1. GovernanceWho would run the strategy?
2. MoneyWho pays for space in New Mexico: state, federal or private sources? (Your $100 million goes in Step 3.)
3. Access to spaceWhich New Mexico sites and companies reach space, and what's missing
4. Flagship programsThe one project New Mexico should be known for
5. Commercial policy toolsGrants, tax breaks, contracts or licensing that would bring companies here
6. International alignmentWhich countries, states or federal programs New Mexico should partner with, and whether it would join the Artemis Accords, the ILRS, both or neither (explain why in the memo)
7. WorkforceWhere the engineers and technicians come from, and how to keep them

For each answer, write two columns: New Mexico today and your plan.

Step 3: spend New Mexico's $100 million. Buy from the menu, the same way you did in class: menu number, item, amount, the framework question it answers, and a short reason. The total must come to $100 million over five years.

✎ Type into the student deck Part B · In the student deck

The memo

Write a memo to the governor by typing it into the memo slides at the end of the student deck, one section per slide, about 800 to 1,200 words in all (two to three pages' worth). It must address your playbook and each of the seven framework questions. Fill in the memo heading (To, From, Date, Subject) and these five sections:

1

Recommendation. In two or three sentences: which playbook (or mix of two), and the single most important first step. If you mix two, say what each one contributes.

2

Why New Mexico. Three New Mexico assets from your Lecture 1 research (your group's site from class and the entities you found for Homework 1) that make this playbook work here.

3

The seven framework questions. A few sentences on each, making the case for the plan you recorded in Part A. Two of them need more:

3a

Money: where the money comes from, and of the items you listed in Part A, Step 3, which comes first and why it's worth more than the others.

3b

International alignment: imagine New Mexico were its own sovereign nation, with defense contracts with many nations, including the United States. Would there be any advantages to joining the ILRS rather than the Artemis Accords? Which would you join: Artemis, the ILRS, both or neither? Use the pros and cons from class, and New Mexico's own assets, to explain.

4

Lessons from abroad. One country whose move New Mexico should copy, and one mistake New Mexico should avoid. Your examples can come from anything we've covered this semester, not just this lecture. You can also choose another nation you think offers a model or a warning; if you do, justify your answer.

5

Risk. One thing that could go wrong, like a twist card from class, and how your plan survives it.

End the memo with a short list of sources: a link for each, or where the information came from if there's no link.

Same rule: you may not recommend funding for an organization where you currently work.
For the in-class exercise

Twist cards

Your instructor deals one of these to each group, picked to hit that group's biggest bet. Each one really happened. This section is for the second part of the in-class exercise. Your instructor will tell you when to use it, so don't read it until then.

If you bought a spaceport

Your spaceport has no rocket

January–April 2023

The first launch from Spaceport Cornwall, in England, fails to reach orbit and loses all nine satellites. Three months later the launch company, Virgin Orbit, goes bankrupt. The spaceport is built, but nothing can launch from it.

Your move: the money is spent. Do you pay to attract a new launch company, or leave the spaceport idle?

Source: Euronews: Virgin Orbit declares bankruptcy

If you're building a rocket

Your first flight fails

October 21, 2021

South Korea's Nuri reaches the right altitude, but its third stage shuts down early and the dummy satellite falls short of orbit. The next try comes eight months later.

Your move: your rocket is now a year late. Do you buy launches abroad in the meantime? From where?

Source: Everyday Astronaut: Nuri's maiden flight

If you bought launches abroad

Your launch provider walks away

February 26, 2022

After sanctions over the invasion of Ukraine, Russia stops all Soyuz launches from Europe's spaceport and pulls its 87 workers out. European satellites booked on Soyuz, including two Galileo navigation satellites, have no ride.

Your move: your launches on the cancelled rocket are gone. Rebook on another one: it costs more, and you wait.

Source: Space.com: Russia halts Soyuz launches from French Guiana

Any group

A new government cuts your budget

May–June 2023

Australia's new government cuts $77 million from three space programs, including its spaceports program. A month later it cancels its A$1.2 billion Earth-observation satellite program for "budget repair."

Your move: lose $200 million of the money you haven't spent yet. What goes?

Sources: Information Age: space program cuts; AFP via Phys.org

If you're in both Moon clubs

Export rules block your payload

September 2022–March 2023

The UAE agrees to fly its Rashid 2 Moon rover on China's Chang'e-7 mission. Six months later, reports confirm the deal is blocked: the rover contains US-made parts, and US export rules (ITAR) keep them off a Chinese spacecraft.

Your move: your payload has US parts and is booked on an ILRS mission. Redesign it without them (more money, a year late), or move it to a ride on the Artemis side?

Sources: SpaceNews: export rules hit UAE rover deal; South China Morning Post

Acronyms and terms

TermMeaning
AEDUAE dirham, the UAE's currency
Artemis AccordsUS-led principles for peaceful exploration of the Moon and beyond, signed country by country
ASESAgence Sénégalaise d’Études Spatiales, Senegal's space agency since 2023
CFA francThe currency of Senegal and several other West African countries, pegged to the euro at about 656 francs per euro
CubeSatA small, standard-sized satellite built from 10 cm cubes, popular with universities
EARExport Administration Regulations, US Commerce Department rules on exporting dual-use technology, including many satellite parts
GatewayA small space station NASA planned to put in a near-rectilinear halo orbit (NRHO) around the Moon: a long, stretched-out loop that passes about 3,000 km above the lunar north pole and about 70,000 km above the south pole, about once a week. Cancelled in March 2026 in favor of a Moon Base on the surface
ILRSInternational Lunar Research Station, the China–Russia lunar base project
ITARInternational Traffic in Arms Regulations, US State Department rules on exporting defense and some space technology
KASAKorea AeroSpace Administration, South Korea's space agency since 2024
NuriSouth Korea's own medium rocket, also called KSLV-II
RHURadioisotope heater unit: a small nuclear heat source, about 1 watt, that keeps spacecraft parts warm
RideshareA launch where many small satellites share one rocket and split the cost
RTGRadioisotope thermoelectric generator: turns nuclear decay heat into electricity for a spacecraft
SARSynthetic aperture radar, an imaging radar that sees through clouds and at night
SpaceportA site licensed to launch or land spacecraft